Ebola Cola

04 Jun, 2008

More Guitar Heroism

Posted by: Sk In: Gaming| General

Though I had never heard of Guitar Hero (I), I was fascinated with Guitar Hero II when it came out on the XBox 360. Despite a general personal bias against guitars (I’m a keyboardist), I loved the idea of roleplaying a rockstar without having to play perfectly correct music. So when I found out that Guitar Hero III would be available on PC I decided I had to have it.

Now I’m almost done with Hard songs. I still have to go past “One” and “Raining blood”, and then of course “The devil went down to Georgia”. One would think that I have still quite some time to spend practicing on my Xplorer replica, and then the news: Guitar Hero IV is coming down on Earth for the mortals to enjoy!

But the plot thickened yesterday, when I found out that there will be no episode IV (and no, it won’t be called “A new hope” instead). Activision is going to release two. Guitar Hero: Aerosmith will be probably just a GHIII reprint with a new tracklist dominated by the Aerosmith, who are reportedly working in collaboration with the developers to deliver us a great rock game. The expected release date should be near according to guitarhero-4.com, who goes as far as talking of June 2008.

Guitar Hero: World Tour is going to be a Rock Band competitor instead. The trailers available on the official Guitar Hero website hint at two multiplayer modes… or rather two “multi-band” modes, the competitive Battle of the Bands and a cooperative mode where up to 8 players can take part divided into 4-members bands. According the the site, the release date is announced for the fall of 2008.

While it’s unquestionable that an episode of a franchise like Guitar Hero can’t live forever (in the end it’s all about learning to play some songs), personally I think Activision is milking it too much. Drums and voice are a great new feature, but the Aerosmith game could have been saved for a future release. Two games in a few months (three in less than a year, if you count GHIII) are too much even for the most hardcore fans, especially if you consider that a drummer hero will have to buy a fake electronic drumset. Coming to think of it, I first played GHII little more than a year ago, and it hadn’t been out for a very long time.

A nice move would be making the drumset a MIDI controller. This way, one could have a game controller and a beginner’s drum kit for “real” music. It’s bad that nobody thinks of adding keyboards to such a virtual band - or maybe it’s actually for the good.

5 Responses to "More Guitar Heroism"

1 | Andrew

June 19th, 2008 at 10:11 am

Avatar

See, this is what gets me. Why don’t people actually just play the instruments?

It’s like the sheer pointlessness of playing Tennis on a Wii.

By next year we’ll have Basoon Hero, Xylophone hero and Opera Hero.

2 | Sk

June 20th, 2008 at 7:31 am

Avatar

I’ll state my case. I’ve played keyboards for about 10 years, and I’ve been the keyboardist in a band for two years (plus some months in a spare time project who never got off the ground). I’ve occasionally played drums, bass and guitar during this period, or rather I tried to.

Well, while my technique is far from good, I can play an almost decent bass and I can provide basic drum patterns, but I never got around to playing the axe. I know that Guitar Hero’s is not a guitar, but playing *with* it is the closest one can get to a guitar without going all the way to the guitar.

You see, what many people (players and critics) don’t get is that clearly the controller is not a guitar. You may claim, if you wish, that it is another sort of musical instrument, even though that is improper.

Anyway, it requires a set of skills similar to those of a guitar player, though much simpler. By playing Guitar Hero, I found that my left hand’s fingers (those who I use less when playing modern music on the keyboards) had improved their mobility. Of course it’s not like practicing Bach for 8 hours a day for five years, but it’s a healthy exercise nonetheless.

A different thing is drums or vocals. Singing for a game is just the same as actual singing, and drumming on a game set is the same as playing an electronic drum set. In the latter case you still know nothing about hitting the snare in twenty different ways and places, but that is lost on electronic sets, too.

As to tennis, not everyone can afford to build a tennis court in his yard, or rent one, unless he’s spent his childhood in expensive tennis courses. The same goes for golf and bowling. It is much funnier and safer to boxe with a Wiimote rather than on a real ring. And while it will never be like the real thing, you still have to achieve that tiny bit of cohordination that is an improvement over everyday exercise.

3 | Andrew

June 20th, 2008 at 8:52 am

Avatar

Yeah I know it’s fun to play, either on your own or with friends. What I don’t understand though are the ‘hardcore’ people that take it far too seriously. I mean the type that don’t seem to grasp that Guitar Hero is just a game, and not a real guitar. They spend day-in and day-out trying to perfect it and all it really goes down to is nothing. Buy a damn Guitar if you’re that serious. That’s what I mean.

I also think that someone who can afford to purchase a Wii can also afford the money for a basic Tennis club membership.

4 | Sk

June 20th, 2008 at 9:08 am

Avatar

Then I definitely agree. I’ve stopped progressing at the beginning of Expert level (and I still can’t complete those two Hard songs), and now I play when I want to have fun with beautiful songs or with interesting rythms or passages. Because it may not be a guitar, but succeeding in “Knights of Cydonia”’s synth riff *does* make your day…

5 | Shaun

June 20th, 2008 at 9:39 am

Avatar

Most people that can play real guitar are hopeless at Guitar Hero, I’ve seen good examples of this in the past.

Just my two cents.

Comment Form

About

WHAT IS THIS SHIT? Our domain name comes from a fictional drink in the Ellis comic, Transmetropolitan.

This is our blog. We thrive on the word "geek" and many of us are mere IT students with only a basic grasp of English.

It is all about enjoyment, passion and sometimes hatred for what we blog about.

We can't afford to eat...